Alerts Sign-up
As the Oscars approach, a Catholic film critic has shared her thoughts on this year's Best Picture nominees. Sister Hosea Rupprecht, associate director of the Pauline Center for Media Studies and a Daughter of St. Paul, expressed mixed feelings about the films she reviewed.
Sister Rupprecht acknowledged that while some nominated films showcased creative and skillful filmmaking, they did not all align with her faith-based criteria. She emphasized the importance of how films treat human dignity and whether they uphold values taught by Jesus.
"The Brutalist," featuring Adrien Brody as László Tóth, was criticized for its portrayal of characters who lacked moral integrity. "The way various characters treated each other in this film was deplorable," she noted.
"A Complete Unknown," a biopic about Bob Dylan played by Timothée Chalamet, highlighted Dylan's transition from acoustic to electric guitar. Sister Rupprecht observed that despite his talent, Dylan appeared ungrateful to those who supported him.
"Conclave," starring Ralph Fiennes as Cardinal Lawrence, drew criticism for its depiction of church leadership. Sister Rupprecht found it lacking in faith and realism regarding the sacred ritual of a conclave.
"Dune: Part Two" was compared to an epic like "Lord of the Rings." The story follows Paul Atreides (Timothée Chalamet) as he embraces his destiny on planet Arrakis. Despite its complexity, Sister Rupprecht appreciated its narrative depth.
"Emilia Pérez," a musical celebrating LGBTQ+ themes, left Sister Rupprecht feeling sympathetic towards its characters due to their struggles with identity and acceptance.
In "Nickel Boys," Ethan Herisse portrays Elwood, a young man enduring abuse at Nickel Academy. Sister Rupprecht praised the film for honoring human dignity and hope amidst adversity.
"The Substance" explores themes of aging and celebrity culture through Elisabeth Sparkle (Demi Moore). The film's horror elements served as commentary on society's obsession with youth and beauty.
"Wicked," adapted from the Broadway musical, follows Elphaba (Cynthia Erivo) as she navigates life at Shiz University in Oz. The film raises questions about wickedness and personal choice.
Sister Rupprecht expressed her preference for "Nickel Boys" as it best captured the essence of human dignity against all odds. However, industry buzz suggests that "Anora" might win Best Picture on March 2nd.
Sister Hosea Rupprecht continues to contribute her insights into media through her work at the Pauline Center for Media Studies.
