Alerts Sign-up
Twenty U.S. Catholic bishops have joined an interfaith coalition to oppose the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, a legislative proposal supporting President Donald Trump's agenda on taxes and immigration. The bill, which is being drafted by the Senate after passing in the House in May, has been labeled a "moral failure" by these religious leaders.
A letter organized by Archbishop John C. Wester of Santa Fe was issued on June 26, urging senators to reject the bill. The letter was signed by over 40 faith leaders from various traditions. It stated: “We believe that the changes made by the U.S. Senate to the legislation are insufficient and do not significantly mitigate its adverse effects.”
Archbishop Wester emphasized that this legislation contradicts Catholic social teachings and expressed concern for its impact on immigrants, families, and those reliant on government assistance for healthcare needs. He described it as "a very draconian kind of a bill."
The letter also criticized provisions of the bill that allocate funds for mass deportation efforts and expressed concerns about potential infringements on houses of worship due to enforcement actions. Additionally, it objected to proposed cuts in healthcare coverage and food assistance programs.
Among those joining Archbishop Wester were several other bishops including Cardinal Robert W. McElroy of Washington and Cardinal Joseph W. Tobin of Newark, New Jersey. Representatives from Protestant, Jewish, and Islamic faiths also supported the letter.
In a separate communication through the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), there was acknowledgment of certain positive aspects within the bill but significant concerns were raised about its potential harm to vulnerable populations.
Archbishop Timothy P. Broglio highlighted issues such as tax breaks favoring wealthier individuals while cutting support like nutrition assistance and Medicaid for others.
Pro-life groups have shown support for aspects of the bill related to Planned Parenthood funding cuts; however, Archbishop Wester cautioned against increasing poverty levels which could lead to higher abortion rates.
The Senate's Republican majority can only afford three defections if they wish to pass this legislation without Democratic backing.
