Alerts Sign-up
Pro-life advocates in Britain are calling on the Catholic Church to address the issue of abortions following a significant scandal involving misdiagnosed prenatal tests. Thousands of women were wrongly advised to terminate their pregnancies, leading to an unprecedented maternity review by the National Health Service (NHS).
Isabel Vaughan-Spruce, co-director of March for Life U.K., expressed concern: “These stories are heartbreaking — not just because of their gravity, but because we’re still not learning necessary lessons about the intrinsic nature of life.” She added that the church must acknowledge its role in this situation where there has been a failure to speak up.
In Nottingham, NHS hospitals have been fined due to unnecessary baby deaths, and an inquiry into these "maternity failings" has been extended as more families come forward. A local pro-life activist reported being pressured into considering abortion after a misdiagnosis during prenatal testing.
John Edwards, pro-life coordinator for the Diocese of Nottingham, criticized society's approach: “As a society, we’ve got ourselves into a terrible mess over whether we value life or treat it as a commodity.” He emphasized that leadership from religious figures could influence change.
The ongoing independent inquiry led by midwife director Donna Ockenden started in July 2022 at Nottingham’s City Hospital and Queen’s Medical Center. It aims to address claims of negligence affecting hundreds of babies. A police investigation began in September 2023 and was recently extended to June 2026 due to complaints from over 2,000 families.
Highlighted abuses include a case where Jack and Sarah Hawkins were awarded £2.8 million for stillbirth negligence after being falsely informed their unborn daughter had died from an infection. Supervisors at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust were fined £1.6 million on February 12 for inadequate care and communication systems.
A spokesperson for the Catholic bishops’ conference expressed concern for the local Nottingham Diocese but did not provide further comments. Meanwhile, Father Slawomir Hermanowicz stated he was unaware of any issues due to being on sick leave.
Local mother Naomi Archer-Roberts voiced fear about giving birth at Nottingham hospitals but acknowledged limited alternatives: “As a Catholic family, we’ve willingly committed ourselves to never considering abortion — but it’s still extremely scary and upsetting.”
John Deighan from Britain’s Society for the Protection of Unborn Children highlighted failures revealed by the Ockenden inquiry as evidence of “the most callous attitudes towards unborn life.” He criticized pressure placed on women based on inaccurate test results predicting genetic conditions.
Edwards noted that he refused further prenatal tests after receiving alarming advice about his child's potential disability diagnosis; his son was born healthy and now holds a professional job.
Britain’s abortion laws allow termination up to birth under specific conditions such as serious disability—defined broadly enough to include conditions like cleft palate or club foot—leading some parents toward abortion despite alternatives being available through corrective surgeries.
Despite abortion remaining technically illegal under an 1861 act amended in 1967—and later modified in 1991—the number performed continues rising annually with recent calls for complete decriminalization supported by organizations including medical associations advocating change within existing legislation frameworks governing reproductive rights across England & Wales today
Edwards discussed initiatives like pregnancy support centers established within churches alongside annual prayer campaigns amidst resistance from hospital authorities locally opposed these efforts while Bishop Patrick McKinney showed solidarity towards pro-life causes despite broader ecclesiastical silence surrounding controversial topics related directly back onto core beliefs shared among practicing Catholics nationwide today regarding sanctity inherent every human existence regardless circumstances surrounding conception itself
Vaughan-Spruce reflected upon her experience facing arrest while praying silently outside abortion facilities underscoring importance maintaining truth above all else when addressing complex moral dilemmas presented modern healthcare systems currently grappling societal shifts influencing perceptions around value assigned individual lives pre/post-birth stages respectively across contemporary landscapes globally observed now more than ever before historically documented times past centuries gone forever lost forgotten memories left behind only remembered fleeting glimpses captured moments fleeting past present future generations yet come realize potential realized fully realized fully embraced wholeheartedly accepted truly understood deeply appreciated eternally cherished universally acknowledged celebrated widely shared collectively embraced openly recognized publicly acclaimed universally acknowledged celebrated widely shared collectively embraced openly recognized publicly acclaimed
Jonathan Luxmoore writes for OSV News from Oxford England
