Alerts Sign-up
"The Best Christmas Pageant Ever," a film adaptation of Barbara Robinson's 1972 children's novel, offers holiday entertainment suitable for various age groups. Directed by Dallas Jenkins, the movie blends humor and drama while conveying valuable insights.
The story unfolds in a small-town church preparing for its annual yuletide pageant. When the long-standing director Mrs. Armstrong, played by Mariam Bernstein, is sidelined by an accident, Grace (Judy Greer), a stay-at-home mom, volunteers to direct the show.
Grace faces challenges when the Herdman children, known for their misbehavior and led by Imogene (Beatrice Schneider), take on principal roles in the pageant. Despite her fears of potential disaster, Grace gives them a chance to prove themselves. Her daughter Beth (Molly Belle Wright) supports her decision, while her husband Bob (Pete Holmes) provides guarded support. However, some parishioners oppose her efforts.
Narrated by adult Beth (Lauren Graham), the film depicts a mutual conversion story where characters gain a deeper understanding of Christmas's true meaning. The Herdman children bring fresh perspectives that help renew others' faith.
Written by Ryan Swanson, Platte F. Clark, and Darin McDaniel, the script addresses themes such as prejudice and positive religious influences with care. These elements outweigh any quasi-irreverent language used to illustrate the Herdmans' naughtiness.
The film is recommended for adults and adolescents but may not interest younger children due to mild oaths and one rude expression. OSV News classifies it as A-II — suitable for adults and adolescents — while the Motion Picture Association rates it PG.
John Mulderig reviewed "The Best Christmas Pageant Ever" for OSV News. Follow him on X @JohnMulderig1.
