Alerts Sign-up
As the U.S. presidential election approaches, Catholic voters are examining Republican candidate Donald J. Trump's support for in vitro fertilization (IVF) and his proposal to make it more accessible through federal or private insurance mandates. The Catholic Church opposes IVF due to ethical concerns, including the destruction of human embryos.
OSV News sought a statement from Trump's campaign on September 12 but received endorsements from Catholic supporters and a link to a press announcement instead. Father Tad Pacholczyk from the National Catholic Bioethics Center noted that many Catholics lack understanding of church teachings on IVF.
In 2021, over 413,000 artificial reproductive technology cycles were recorded, resulting in about 97,128 births according to the CDC. The Vatican's documents "Donum Vitae" and "Dignitas Personae" express concerns about IVF equating it with abortion and commodifying human life.
Father Pacholczyk emphasized that IVF replaces natural procreation with laboratory procedures, which he argues undermines human dignity. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has not commented on potential Trump policies but reiterated its stance on life dignity.
Trump has publicly supported IVF access during his campaign, stating his administration would ensure coverage for IVF treatments. However, details remain unclear as Lyman Stone from the Institute for Family Studies highlighted uncertainties regarding policy implementation and potential costs estimated at $55 billion over ten years by Patrick T. Brown from the Ethics and Public Policy Center.
Timothy P. Carney from the American Enterprise Institute raised questions about coverage specifics like eligibility criteria and surrogacy inclusion. Senate Republicans have blocked related legislation citing insurance cost concerns.
Father Pacholczyk warned against mandatory coverage as an intrusion into religious practices while noting conscience issues similar to past debates over healthcare mandates involving religious groups.
The pro-life voting bloc may find itself conflicted by Trump's position on IVF despite his broader support among conservative circles.
Kimberley Heatherington reports for OSV News with contributions from Peter Jesserer Smith.
